Shohei Ohtani Could Pitch Again in This World Series. What Role Would Make Sense?

Key Highlights

  • Shohei Ohtani told Japanese reporters he would prepare to pitch in Toronto this weekend for Game 7.
  • The “Ohtani Rule” allows him to remain as a designated hitter after pitching, but not if entering as a reliever.
  • Ohtani could be used as a starter or closer; the Dodgers have been monitoring his workload carefully.
  • With the series tied at two games apiece, there will be a Game 6 at Rogers Centre regardless of who wins Wednesday’s Game 5.

The “Ohtani Rule” and Its Implications

In an intriguing development for baseball fans, Shohei Ohtani, the two-way star of the Los Angeles Dodgers, has announced his intention to pitch again in this World Series. This move, if realized, would test the boundaries set by Major League Baseball’s “Ohtani Rule.” The rule, officially known as the Two-Way Player Designation, allows a player with both pitching and hitting abilities to remain in the game after leaving the mound. However, there are specific conditions attached to this flexibility.

Role Options for Ohtani

If Ohtani were to pitch again in Toronto, his role could be either as a starter or closer. The reasoning behind considering these options lies in Major League Baseball’s rules regarding two-way players. According to the rule, if Ohtani were to enter as a reliever, he would lose his designated hitter status when leaving the game. This presents a strategic dilemma for the Dodgers: they must weigh the benefits of having Ohtani on the mound against potential downsides in terms of his hitting contributions.

Using Ohtani as a Starter

The most straightforward option would be to start Ohtani in Game 7. This approach aligns with the “Ohtani Rule,” allowing him to remain in the game both as a pitcher and a hitter without additional complications. However, this decision comes with its own set of challenges. The Dodgers have been cautious about Ohtani’s workload since his return from injury, making the decision on how often he pitches a delicate balancing act.

Using Ohtani as a Closer

An alternative strategy would be to use Ohtani in a more specialized role, such as a closer. This approach could leverage his pitching prowess while avoiding the pitfalls of reliever usage. However, this option requires careful consideration due to the unique nature of Ohtani’s previous experience as a closer during the 2023 World Baseball Classic. His ability to pitch effectively and maintain control in high-pressure situations would be crucial.

Manager Roberts Weighs Options

Dodgers manager Dave Roberts indicated that the team would check in with Ohtani about his readiness this weekend, leaving the door open for a potential return. Roberts emphasized the importance of considering Ohtani’s condition and whether it makes sense to have him pitch again. Given the series’ current state—tied at two games apiece—and the impending Game 6 at Rogers Centre, the timing is critical.

Roberts acknowledged the strategic implications: “If he can go, if it makes sense, certainly he would be an option.” This statement reflects the complex decision-making process involved in determining whether and how to use Ohtani. The manager’s cautious approach underscores the significance of this potential return for both the Dodgers and their rivals.

Conclusion

The possibility of Shohei Ohtani pitching again in this World Series remains a topic of speculation. Whether as a starter or closer, his return would undoubtedly impact the series dynamics. The “Ohtani Rule” provides flexibility but also introduces challenges that must be carefully navigated by the Dodgers. As the series progresses, fans will be watching closely to see how these strategic decisions unfold.