If Not Pete Alonso, Then Who at First Base for the Mets?

Mets’ First Base Dilemma: Bringing Back Pete Alonso or Exploring Options?

The New York Mets find themselves at a crossroads for their first base position in the 2026 season. The team is considering bringing back their star player, Pete Alonso, who had a significant impact on the lineup. Alternatively, they are also exploring internal options and external free agent and trade prospects to strengthen this critical position.

Internal Options: Brandon Nimmo, Jeff McNeil, Mark Vientos, Brett Baty

The Mets have several players who could fill the first base role internally. Brandon Nimmo, a versatile outfielder, has shown potential at first base but may struggle with the defensive demands of the position. Similarly, Jeff McNeil, a reliable infielder, has experience splitting time between third and first bases.

Mark Vientos and Brett Baty are younger prospects who could contribute at first base but may need further development to meet the team’s expectations. These players bring offensive potential, with Vientos hitting 53 home runs in three seasons and Baty showing a solid batting average despite limited experience.

Tiered Free Agent Options: Alex Bregman, Cody Bellinger, Eugenio Suárez

If the Mets decide to go outside their organization for first base options, they have several notable free agents at their disposal. Alex Bregman, a three-time All-Star, brings a wealth of experience and a high WAR value despite his age. However, his salary demands may make him an expensive option.

Cody Bellinger and Eugenio Suárez are younger players with strong offensive skills but have faced questions regarding their defense at first base. Bellinger’s power hitting is a clear asset, while Suárez has shown the ability to bat cleanup and provide clutch hits.

Tier 2 Rebuild Options: Marcell Ozuna, Christian Walker, Alec Bohm

The Mets are also considering rebuilding options that could aggregate to form a strong first base presence. Marcell Ozuna, known for his defensive prowess and power hitting, would be an intriguing fit if the team is willing to trade for him. However, his high salary may pose challenges.

Christian Walker offers a solid combination of power and defense but will require a significant financial commitment from the Mets. Alec Bohm, a versatile player with experience at first base, could provide immediate impact while potentially offering long-term value through arbitration.

Tier 3 Leap of Faith Options: Carlos Santana, Austin Hays

For those willing to take a risk, the Mets have options like Carlos Santana, who has shown flashes of greatness but may require significant improvement in his approach at the plate. Similarly, Austin Hays, known for his defense and potential, could offer a unique combination of skills that might benefit the team.

The Mets’ decision on first base will be crucial as they aim to compete for a playoff spot in 2026. The options presented here provide a comprehensive look at their choices, balancing offensive output with defensive capabilities and financial considerations.