Key Highlights
- The Best Neo-Western of the 2020s Is Not Yellowstone
- Dark Winds is praised for its perfect Rotten Tomatoes score and realistic crime elements
- Yellowstone, despite being a family drama with a Hollywood star, is still considered among the best neo-Western shows
The Best Neo-Western of the 2020s: A Controversial Debate
Dramatic twists and gripping plots have long been hallmarks of the Western genre. However, in recent years, this classic American narrative has taken on a modern twist with neo-Westerns. In his article “The Best Neo-Western Of The Decade Is Not Yellowstone,” Guy Howie from ScreenRant delves into the debate over which show truly reigns supreme among its contemporaries.
The Pinnacle of Westerns: Dark Winds
Dark Winds, a crime thriller set in the 1970s, has emerged as a standout contender. Its third season debuted on Rotten Tomatoes with a perfect score of 100%, solidifying its status as the best neo-Western TV series of the 2020s so far.
The show, based on novelist Tony Hillerman’s Leaphorn & Chee stories, is lauded for its nuanced portrayal of Native American culture. Characters like Joe Leaphorn (Zahn McClarnon) and Jim Chee (Kiowa Gordon), law enforcement officers working in the Four Corners area, are deeply rooted in their cultural identities. The series balances crime-solving with rich cultural narratives, ensuring a deep and meaningful experience for viewers.
A Family Drama with Hollywood Presence: Yellowstone
Yellowstone, while not as critically acclaimed, is still considered among the best neo-Westerns available on streaming platforms. The show follows the Dutton family’s struggle to maintain their vast ranch in the face of external threats, offering a family drama wrapped in Western attire.
The series finale broke streaming records with over 11 million viewers tuning in for its conclusion. Kevin Costner, the legendary star behind Yellowstone, commands significant attention and is an initial draw for many audiences. However, his status as a Hollywood mega-star contrasts starkly with the more nuanced portrayals found in Dark Winds.
The Debate Continues: A Must-Watch Gem
While Dark Winds garners overwhelming praise, Yellowstone remains a significant player. Both series offer unique perspectives on the Western genre’s revival. For fans of the neo-Western subgenre, it’s clear that Dark Winds is an undervalued gem, despite not being technically categorized as a neo-Western.
In conclusion, while Yellowstone may hold a special place in the hearts of many viewers due to its family melodrama and Hollywood star power, critics argue that Dark Winds is the superior neo-Western. Its perfect Rotten Tomatoes score and gritty realism make it a compelling choice for Western enthusiasts.
Which show do you prefer? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!
